Sunday, August 27, 2023

"No Person Above Sixty Years of Age" - The Massachusetts Alarm Lists of Lexington and Concord

About two weeks ago, a question was posed on the Facebook discussion page “Progressive Rev War Reenactors” regarding what Massachusetts alarm lists were and what their role was on the eve of Lexington and Concord.

The Nerds, as well as several far more qualified (and admittedly better-looking) historians, chimed in on the topic. The result was a cursory overview of the Massachusetts militia system alarm lists.

But what are alarm lists, and what were their contributions to the wartime buildup on the eve of the American Revolution?

As a preliminary matter, Massachusetts colonial laws required men between the ages of sixteen and sixty to serve in their local militia company. Every town maintained at least one militia company and the units were organized into county-level regiments based upon location within the geographic jurisdiction. For example, the militia companies of the Merrimack Valley region of Essex County, Massachusetts, were organized into a regiment known as the “4th Essex Regiment of Foot”.

Within this militia system were the alarm lists. Alarm lists were essentially the "home guard" or the last line of defense for a community. Generally speaking, most alarm list members were over sixty. However, we have seen hints that some Middlesex and Essex County communities transferred men as young as fifty-five into the alarm list.

In addition to “older” males, alarm lists often included male residents between the ages of sixteen and sixty who did not serve in the town’s militia system. Most likely, these would have included males who were temporarily infirm or disabled or men ordered by the selectmen to serve in the alarm lists.


Alarm lists appear to be an 18th-century construct, as 17th-century Massachusetts colonial militia laws do not reference the term or concept. Similarly, early and mid-18th century amendments to the 1697 Militia Act do not reference Alarm Lists. In fact, the first official reference to such a reserve force appears to be in the 1757 Massachusetts Militia Act. However, based on the law's language and the lack of instructions on establishing and organizing alarm lists, the Nerds suspect the 1757 law was most likely a codification of an ongoing practice already in place rather than creating a whole new system. Admittedly, further research is needed, but It is suspected that the alarm list system developed in conjunction with the French Wars moving further west and north away from Massachusetts.

In the late 17th and 18th Centuries, the Massachusetts Colonial Legislature also passed a series of laws dictating how militia and non-commissioned officers were chosen, what arms and equipment militiamen should carry, and how often they should train. For example, the 1697 Militia Act required “That every listed souldier and other householder (except ' troopers) shall be alwayes provided with a well fixt firelock musket, of) musket or bastard musket bore, the barrel not less then three foot and a half long, or other good firearms to the satisfaction of the commission officers of the company, a snapsack, a coller with twelve bandeleers or cartouch-box, one pound of good powder, twenty bullets fit for his gun, and twelve flints, a good sword or cutlace, a worm and priming-wire fit for his gun ; on penalty of six shillings for want of such arms as is hereby required, and two shillings for each other defect, and the like "sum for every four weeks he shall remain unprovided, the fine to be paid by parents for their sons under age and under their command, and by masters or heads of families for their servants, other than servants upon wages.”

Similarly, before the Massachusetts wartime buildup of 1774/1775, militia companies were legally required to hold four training days per year plus two additional days for military “instruction” and “inspection” of arms and equipment.

The laws governing alarm lists generally mirrored those of militia companies. Members of alarm lists were required to hold elections to choose their officers, non-commissioned officers and clerks. They were also expected to acquire the same arms and equipment that a militia company was required to have. For example, a 1776 Massachusetts militia act declared that the men of alarm lists “shall, respectively, provide for, and equip themselves with, such arms and accoutrements as by this act is directed for those of the training- band in the militia, aforesaid”.

However, there were some exceptions and limitations with alarm lists that militia companies did not have. 


Alarm lists were not required to meet four times a year to drill and only had to assemble twice annually to inspect arms and equipment. As the 1757 militia law declared, “Every person borne on the alarm list, and not on the train band, shall, on the first Monday in May, and the last training day in the year, annually, between three and five of the clock in the afternoon, and while the trained bands shall be under arms, carry or send his arms and ammunition into the field to be viewed; and in case any person shall neglect or refuse to carry or send his arms and ammunition into the field as aforesaid, unless unavoidably prevented, he shall be liable to the same penalty for each day's neglect, as if he had not such arms and ammunition.”

Furthermore, in times of emergency or threats, such as the Lexington Alarm of 1775, alarm lists could mobilize, leaving the confines of a community to serve side by side with its sister militia company in the field. When such a scenario occurred, Massachusetts militia laws implied that the officers of alarm lists were subordinate to their fellow officers from their community’s militia company. Curiously, the requirement to mobilize with a sister militia unit became voluntary once an alarm list member reached sixty years of age. According to the 1776 Massachusetts Militia Act, “no person above sixty years of age … shall be compelled to march out of the town wherein they have their usual place of abode.”

The January 1776 Massachusetts militia law, entitled An Act For Forming And Regulating The Militia Within The Colony Of The Massachusetts Bay, In New England, And For Repealing All The Laws Heretofore Made For That Purpose, made the most significant change to the alarm list system during the American Revolution by restructuring age requirements of both organizations. Specifically, it restructured the service eligibility of militia and alarm lists. Unless excused by law, those between sixteen and fifty were required to serve in the militia. Men between the ages of fifty and sixty-five were assigned to the alarm lists. Those over sixty-five were outright excused from any service.


With all that said, what role did alarm lists play during the buildup to war or the Battles of Lexington and Concord? 

The short answer is that the alarm's "older men" significantly contributed to the war effort. On September 26, 1774, Lexington selectmen ordered the “alarm list meet for a view of their arms” as part of its wartime effort. On March 6, 1775, the Town of Westborough ordered that men from the alarm list be attached to Captain Brigham’s Minute Company and train on an artillery piece Westborough acquired in the Fall of 1774. By April 3rd, the Reverend Ebenezer Parkman noted the two units were frequently drilling together. Chelmsford ordered in March 1775 that its alarm list be “be equipt with fire arms and ammunition” in preparation for war. Haverhill, Andover and Newburyport’s alarm list companies were routinely “exercising” and “showing arms” with its sister militia and minute man units.

Although most alarm list companies remained behind to protect their communities during the Battles of Lexington and Concord, several alarm lists did mobilize to meet the British threat. As Lexington militiaman Daniel Harrington recounted during the early hours of April 19th, “the train band or Militia, and the alarm men (consisting of the aged and others exempted from turning out, excepting upon alarm) repaired in general to the common, close in with the meeting-house, the usual place of parade; and there were present when the roll was called over about one hundred and thirty of both.” When the Lexington men reformed later in the morning, elements of the alarm list were present with Parker’s men.

it is almost certain that alarm list companies from Cambridge, Lincoln, Concord and other communities mobilized in response to the British incursion into the Middlesex countryside as well.

According to various accounts, Mentomy’s alarm list successfully intercepted a supply wagon meant for the British expedition en route to Concord. Danver’s alarm list quickly mobilized and engaged in a forced march to intercept the British column as it retired towards Boston. Period accounts suggest the age men of Danvers fought side by side with their younger relatives and neighbors during a brutal hand-to-hand fight with His Majesty’s forces in Menotomy.

More research needs to be conducted regarding the contribution of alarm lists during the Battles of Lexington and Concord. The Nerds would like to direct our readers to the only known organization in the New England area portraying an alarm list … the Danvers Alarm List. This organization does a great job memorializing Danvers's contributions to the American Revolution, and they are all-around amazing people. Be sure to follow them on social media.

But that said, we will also ask the obvious … why aren’t there more older reenactors organizing and portraying Massachusetts alarm lists?

Saturday, August 5, 2023

"Found Dead Within A Few Rods Of The House" - The Non-Combatant Casualties of April 19, 1775

The Nerds are once again returning to the Battles of Lexington and Concord and taking a deep dive into the civilian experiences of that fateful day. Today, we will discuss male non-combatants killed by British forces on April 19, 1775.

We became interested in this topic after journalist and entrepreneur Rasheed Walters contacted us to inquire if we knew of any civilians killed that day. The Nerds are aware of five individuals killed by British forces either during their advance on Concord or their retreat back to Boston. Four were adult males, and one was a child. The victims hailed from Woburn, Lexington, Menotomy (present-day Arlington, Massachusetts), and Charlestown.

As a preliminary matter, the Nerds have traditionally defined civilians (or non-combatants) of the Battles of Lexington and Concord as men, women, and children who did not serve in a combat or support role nor carried arms and accouterments in opposition to the British incursion into Middlesex County.

The day's first civilian casualty was Asahel Porter of Woburn.

Well before dawn on April 19, 1775, Porter and Josiah Richardson left Woburn on horseback, allegedly to travel to the Boston market. As the pair entered the Menotomy District of Cambridge, they collided with Colonel Francis Smith’s military expedition bound for Concord. Suspecting the pair were alarm riders, an officer and loyalist guide arrested the pair. According to Lieutenant Jesse Adair of the Marines, “here are 2 fellows galloping express to Alarm the Country, on which I immediately rode up to them, Seized one of them & our guide the other, [and] dismounted them.”

Porter and Richardson were quickly ushered towards the back of the column and placed under guard. However, as the British forces approached the Lexington common, Porter’s captors determined there was no longer a need to detain the pair and the two were released.

At some point after the skirmish commenced, Porter was retreating from his captors and was shot and killed. According to an 1824 deposition of Lexington militia man John Munroe, Porter “attempted to make his escape, and was shot within a few rods of the common.” Another eyewitness, Amos Locke, declared in his 1824 deposition he and his cousin Ebenezer found “Asahel Porter of Woburn shot through the body.”



Lexington's John Raymond was a neighbor of William and Anna Munroe and was employed by the family as a general laborer. Many 19th-century historians have argued Raymond was a “simple man,” and “a cripple”. However, recent research has suggested that he only suffered from a short-term, temporary disability that prevented him from fielding on April 19th.

Following the Battle of Lexington, Raymond watched over the family tavern while Anna Munroe and her children fled the property. That afternoon, British soldiers under the command of Lord Hugh Earle Percy shot and killed Raymond.

William Munroe’s 1825 deposition sheds some light on the circumstances of Raymond’s fate. According to the account, “On the return of the British troops from Concord, they stopped at my tavern house in Lexington and dressed their wounded. I had left my house in the care of a lame man, by the name of Raymond, who supplied them with whatever the house afforded, and afterward, when he was leaving the house, he was shot by the regulars, and found dead within a few rods of the house.”

Munroe’s 1827 obituary also refers to Raymond, noting the militia sergeant “participated with his company in the events of the day, leaving the care of his public house in the superintendance of a neighbor, whom the British killed on their retreat.”

The Menottomy Fight of April 19, 1775, was a brutal and vicious close-quarters fight between British regulars and Massachusetts provincials along the Bay Road. As the fight neared Cooper’s Tavern, Jabez Wyman and his brother-in-law Jason Winship were seated inside, each consuming several pints of alcohol. The ages of both men are unknown, but a period account does suggest the two men were elderly.

As the innkeeper, Benjamin Cooper, and his wife, Rachel, prepared to flee to safety, the pair pleaded for the two men to leave with them. They refused and continued drinking. Moments later, His Majesty’s army attacked Cooper’s Tavern.

Image Source: Minute Man National Park

A month after the Battles of Lexington and Concord, Rachel Cooper would provide a grim and terrifying account of Wyman and Winship’s fate. “The King’s regular troops under the command of General Gage, upon their return from blood and slaughter, which they had made at Lexington and Concord, fired more than one hundred bullets into the house where we dwell, through doors, and windows,…The two aged gentlemen [Winship and Wyman] were immediately most barbarously and inhumanly murdered by them, being stabbed through in many places, their heads mangled, skulls broke, and their brains out on the floor and walls of the house.”

The Rev John Marrett of Woburn’s Second Parish would later discuss the two men in a letter to his uncle, Rev Isaiah Dunster. In his correspondence, he noted the pair “died as a fool dieth.”

As the afternoon wore on, it became clear that His Majesty’s troops were quickly approaching Charlestown. In response, many residents of that community chose to flee. However, a fourteen-year-old child named Edward Barber remained behind. Little is known about the exact circumstances of his death, but a period account suggests his curiosity got the better of him. Barber was fired upon as while inside a house watching the British retreat. 

That evening, Jacob Rogers of Charlestown received news that his brother-in-law, “a youth of fourteen, was shot dead on the neck of land by the soldiers, as he was looking out of a window. I stayed a little while to console them.”

Sadly, the famed broadside entitled Bloody Butchery by the British Troops only identified Edward as “Capt. William Barber's son, aged 14”.

Saturday, June 10, 2023

“Went Hallooing and Frolicking Through the Streets” - New England's Day of Darkness

With much of the Northeast United States enveloped in a weird, thick yellow smoke from the wildfires of Canada, the Nerds thought they would share an example of a similar event that struck Massachusetts and most of the northern colonies on May 19, 1780.

The sun rose, as usual, that day, but then the skies over New England quickly darkened. According to a 19th century account, “a dark dense cloud gradually rose out of the West and spread itself until the heavens were entirely covered, except at the horizon, where a narrow rim of light remained.”

In Weston, Massachusetts, merchant Samuel Phillips Savage marveled that a veil the color of cider had descended “over the whole visible heavens.”

George Washington, stationed in Connecticut with the Continental Army, reported the "Dark Day" in his diary. He wrote "Heavy & uncommon kind of Clouds--dark & at the same time a bright and reddish kind of light intermixed with them--brightning & darkning alternately. This continued till afternoon when the sun began to appear. The Wind in the Morning was Easterly. After that it got to the Westward."

The darkness was so complete that candles were required from noon onward. Connecticut’s Joseph Joslin was forced to abandon work on a stone wall for want of light. 

Could your thunder buddy have saved you during the 1780 Day of Darkness?
 

Samuel Phillips Savage noted that a neighbor stopped shoveling manure when he realized he couldn’t “discern the difference between the ground and the dung.”

“The fowls retired to roost,” Harvard professor Samuel Williams wrote, “the cocks were crowing all around, as at break of day; objects could not be distinguished but at a very little distance; and everything bore the appearance of gloom of night.”

Panic, confusion, and terror quickly spread among the residents of many New England communities. Men prayed, and women wept. Many waited in great fear for the arrival of the Four Horsemen.

Schools were closed, and hundreds of colonists left off work to seek refuge in taverns or churches. In Salem, the Rev. Nathaniel Whitaker warned that the Dark Day was the Almighty's wrath for the congregation's sins. Lawyer William Pynchon noted that a group of booze-soaked sailors “went hallooing and frolicking through the streets” of Salem and encouraged the town’s ladies to strip off their clothes and join them in morbid celebration. “Now you may take off your rolls and high caps,” they said, “and be damned.”

At some point, a rainstorm passed through the Merrimack Valley region of Massachusetts. Period accounts described the rain giving off a strong soot smell while the Merrimack River near Amesbury and Newburyport was coated in a black oily film.

One eyewitness described Boston as smelling like a coal kiln. 

A Young Woman Shucking Oysters by Lamplight by Robert Morland
 

Save for a few peeks of sunlight in the afternoon, the shade lingered over the Northeast for the rest of the day. The night that followed was remembered as one of the darkest on record. New Hampshire’s Samuel Tenney deemed it “as gross as ever has been observed since the Almighty fiat gave birth to light…A sheet of white paper held within a few inches of the eyes was equally invisible with the blackest velvet.” 

People slept fitfully, and many worried they would never see daylight. Much to the relief of New England, the shroud of darkness had lifted by the following morning.

What caused this unusual event? A scientific study of old trees in the Algonquin Highlands, Ontario, confirmed what many historians suspected - a massive wildfire in Canadian forests.

After careful examination, scientists found ‘fire scars’, (the presence of charcoal and resin) in the growth rings of the trees. These scars were dated to the same period as the so-called “Day of Darkness”.


Saturday, May 20, 2023

"I Got My Chaise, Took My Wife and Children" - A Male Evacuee's Eyewitness Account of April 19, 1775

Over the past few months. The Nerds have discussed five known accounts of civilians, exclusively of women, who came in direct contact with His Majesty’s forces on April 19, 1775.

First up was Lincoln’s Mary Hartwell, who remembered coming in close contact with retreating British forces just as they were about to enter the Bloody Curve. “I saw an occasional horseman dashing by, going up and down, but heard nothing more until I saw them coming back in the afternoon all in confusion, wild with rage and loud with threats. I knew there had been trouble and that it had not resulted favorably for their retreating army. I heard musket shots just below by the old Brooks Tavern and trembled, believing that our folks were killed.”

As they fled the family tavern, Anna Munroe, wife of Lexington’s Sergeant William Munroe, and her 5-year-old daughter Anna nearly collided with the Royal Artillery and Percy's Relief Column. According to her 19th Century account, the child witness recalled she “could remember seeing the men in redcoats coming toward the house and how frightened her mother was when they ran from the house. That was all she could remember, but her mother told her of her very unhappy afternoon. She held Anna by the hand, brother William by her side and baby Sally in her arms . . . She could hear the cannon firing over her head on the hill. She could smell the smoke of the three buildings which the British burned between here and the center of Lexington. And she did not know what was happening to her husband, who was fighting, or what was happening within her house.”

The most notable female non-combatant who came into direct contact with the retreating British column was Hannah Adams of Menotomy. As previously discussed, the Menotomy Fight of April 19, 1775 was a vicious engagement that devolved into a bloody house-to-house and room-to-room fight for survival. Unfortunately, as this fight raged on, Hannah Adams, who had recently given birth and was bedridden, was trapped between Massachusetts militiamen and British regulars.

Like Hannah Adams, Hannah Bradish of Menotomy was also bedridden on April 19, 1775, having given birth to a child eight days earlier. As the regulars entered Menotomy, Hannah slept in bed with her infant. The sound of gunshots woke her up, and she quickly gathered her children and fled to the family kitchen at the back of the house. According to her statement submitted to the Massachusetts Provincial Congress on May 11, 1775, as she and her family hid behind furniture, bullets peppered her house and nearly struck her.

In a 19th Century newspaper interview, Lexington’s Rebekah Fiske described how she came in contact with His Majesty’s troops on more than one occasion and how she and other women and children were forced to flee from their homes to avoid the running fight between Massachusetts provincials and British regulars.

Recently, historian Katie Turner Getty brought to my attention an account of a male civilian, possibly a loyalist, who came in contact with the retreating column. 

 

Photo Credit: Nadia Peatie, MMNHP

As a preliminary matter, if you are not following Katie Turner Getty’s research efforts, you should. While the Nerds tend to focus on the events of April 19th between Lexington and Concord and the impact of the war in Essex County, Katie has taken a deep dive into Menotomy, Cambridge, and Charlestown’s contributions during the Battles of Lexington and Concord and the impact of the Siege of Boston.  

Two weeks ago, Katie and the Nerds attended the Saratoga 250th's "Women in War Symposium" in New York as presenters. During her lecture, Katie mentioned the exploits of Jacob Rogers and how he and his family came in direct contact with the retiring British forces as they tried to flee Charlestown, Massachusetts. Unbeknownst to the Nerds, J.L. Bell of Boston 1775 has also blogged about the incident.

As discussed in previous blog postings, there are numerous examples of Middlesex County men who qualified for service in the militia yet saw little or no combat on April 19th. Many could be classified as "evacuees" because they cared for their wives, mothers or daughters and assisted in helping them escape from the fight. Others did not fight because of “special circumstances”, including temporary injuries that prevented mobilization with the militia, an inability to secure arms and equipment, or the undertaking of specific duties, such as guarding captured British troops.

It appears Rogers fell under the “evacuee” category.

Jacob Rogers was a lieutenant in the Royal Navy. In 1774, he retired from service on board the HMS Halifax and settled, with his family, in Charlestown.

According to an October 1775 petition to the Massachusetts Legislature, Rogers became aware of the British expedition to Concord early in the morning of April 19th. “We were alarmed with various reports concerning the king’s troops, which put everybody in confusion About ten in the morning I met Doctor [Joseph] Warren riding hastily out of town and asked him if the news was true of the men’s being killed at Lexington; he assured me it was. I replied I was very glad our people had not fired first, as it would have given the king’s troops a handle to execute their project of desolation. He rode on.”

As an aside, the Charlestown militia did not mobilize on April 19, 1775. According to Jacob’s account, the reason why is obvious. “In the afternoon Mr. James Russell … received a letter from General [Thomas] Gage, importing that he was informed the people of Charlestown had gone out armed to oppose his majesty's troops, and that if one single man more went out armed, we might expect the most disagreeable consequences.”

As the afternoon wore on, it became clear that His Majesty’s troops were quickly approaching Charlestown. In response, many residents, including Rogers and his family, chose to flee. “A line-of-battle ship lying before the town; a report that Cambridge bridge was taken up … no other retreat but through Charlestown: numbers of men, women, and children, in this confusion, getting out of town. Among the rest, I got my chaise, took my wife and children; and as I live near the school-house, in a back street, drove into the main street, put my children in a cart with others then driving out of town, who were fired at several times on the common, and followed after. Just abreast of Captain Fenton’s, on the neck of land, Mr. David Waitt, leather-dresser, of Charlestown, came riding in full speed from Cambridge, took hold of my reins, and assisted me to turn up on Bunker’s Hill, as he said the troops were then entering the common.”

Shortly after that, it appears Rogers, his family, Mr. Waitt, and another unknown family came in direct contact with the regulars and were fired upon. “I had just reached the summit of the hill, dismounted from the chaise, and tied it fast in my father-in-law’s pasture, when we saw the troops within about forty rods of us, on the hill. One … Hayley, a tailor, now of Cambridge, with his wife, and a gun on his shoulder, going towards them, drew a whole volley of shot on himself and us, that I expected my wife, or one of her sisters, who were with us, to drop every moment.”
 

Photo Credit: John Collins
 

Rogers and his family continued to flee, apparently changing course and hiding in different locations to avoid the retreating regulars. Eventually, he and his family took refuge in a home near the Charlestown training field. While there, Rogers noted he found the “house full of women and children, in the greatest terror, afraid to go to their own habitations.”

After dark, the former naval officer and a few other Charlestown men walked about the town to determine if it was safe to return home. According to Rogers, “On our way, met a Mr. Hutchinson, who informed us all was then pretty quiet; that when the soldiers came through the street, the officers desired the women and children to keep in doors for their safety; that they begged for drink, which the people were glad to bring them, for fear of their being ill-treated.”

Sadly, upon returning home, Rogers and his wife received news that His Majesty’s troops had killed his fourteen-year-old brother-in-law as they crossed Charlestown Neck. “On our arrival at home, we found that her brother a youth of fourteen, was shot dead on the neck of land by the soldiers, as he was looking out of a window. I stayed a little while to console them, and went into the main street to see if all was quiet, and found an officer and guard under arms by Mr. David Wood’s, baker, who continued, it seems, all night; from thence, seeing everything quiet, came home and went to bed.”

To add to Roger’s misfortune, he attempted to reclaim his chaise the next day. To his chagrin, he discovered “my cushion stole, and many other things I had in the box.”

In the aftermath of Lexington and Concord, Lieutenant Rogers was quickly suspected of rendering aid to the enemy on April 19th. Of course, Rogers denied providing such assistance and ultimately submitted an account of his actions as detailed above.

Rogers and his family eventually moved to the Stoneham and Reading, Massachusetts areas, where they were treated with open hostility by the local residents. Eventually, he and his family were forced to flee to England.

 

"Plan of Charlestown Peninsula in the State of Massachusetts", c. 1818, Digital Commonwealth

Ms. Turner Getty provided a footnote about Lieutenant Rogers’ fate in a research article for the Journal of the American Revolution. In the aftermath of the American Revolution, he submitted a loyalist claim for compensation and openly proclaimed that he rendered material aid to the British troops in the aftermath of Lexington and Concord. Specifically, he asserted, “gave every relief and assistance in his power…to his Majesties’ troops on their retreat to Charles Town in refreshing the Officers and Men [and] procuring surgeons to dress the wounded.”

Thursday, April 27, 2023

"We Support the Site" - Why Criticism of Minute Man National Park's Authenticity Standards Are Misguided

Rarely do the Nerds issue an editorial or commentary on controversial topics or issues within the hobby. Since this blog debuted in 2015, we have only published two editorials. The first was criticizing the awful television production known as “The Sons of Liberty”. The second was criticizing a living history event that made light of the suffering of the wounded and dying in battle.

Today, the Nerds are going against our standard practice and issuing a third editorial. This time we are responding to the criticism of the Battle Road event at Minute Man National Historical Park.

To be fully transparent, our readers should know that the Nerds routinely volunteer our time and effort at Minute Man National Historical Park (MMNHP or the "Park"). We have continuously shared our research findings with the Park. We also contribute to the Battle Road Planning Committee and are members of the site’s Authenticity Committee.
 

 
Over the past two years, we have heard complaints about the new and revised Battle Road tactical demonstrations. Most objections have fallen into one of the following categories:

The Massachusetts provincial forces appear too uniform.
 
The Massachusetts provincial forces appear too clean and wear clothing never worn on April 19, 1775.
 
Many Massachusetts men rushed from their homes into battle. They never intended to travel that far and likely would have returned home after a few hours of fighting. As a result, they never would have fielded with packs and blankets.
 
The guidelines are simply too strict and inflexible. The public doesn’t know any better and many reenactors are being unfairly excluded from participating—a couple of preliminary points in response to these arguments.

First, most objections seem to be coming from the older established units who, for some reason, are resistant to newer research findings. We will be upfront and say we are both surprised and disappointed. Many of these organizations were considered “cutting edge” regarding evolving standards and portrayals during the Bicentennial and 225th celebrations. However, these same units rested on their laurels over the past decade or actively tried to reverse their progress. Honestly, we are curious why!

Second, and more importantly, Minute Man National Park notified all Battle Road participants in 2018 of its intent to revise and upgrade its clothing and equipment standards. The Park also released a timetable for implementing the new standards. Before and during the drafting of the guidelines, every unit that participated in Battle Road was allowed to provide commentary and suggestions.

Very few of those who are currently disparaging the event provided input. Instead, most derided the effort, threatened to boycott, or simply ignored requests for input. A few organizations outright believed, “We’re unit X; they have to accommodate us regardless of whether or not the rules are enforced!”

Predictably, none of these approaches worked well.

From the Nerds' perspective, units that refused or neglected to work with the Park waived their rights to object and are now sitting on the sidelines thanks to their inaction



 With that said, we won’t provide a rundown of documentation countering each argument listed above … we’ve already done that for over the past eight years. There is ample documentation between this blog, Minute Man National Historical Park’s official website, the 18th Century Material Culture Resource Center, RevWar ‘75, and other sites to refute the above mentioned claims.

Similarly, for those who argue the current Battle Road standards defy historical notions and logic, our response is simple… prove the standards wrong. If you claim the material culture of April 19, 1775, is incorrect, it is YOUR responsibility…not ours … to provide documentation supporting your claim.

You cannot simply make a claim, sit back, and demand others disprove your position. Similarly, you cannot ignore requests for documentation. It just doesn’t work that way.

At the end of the day, we respectfully suggest that this all comes down to ego. Participants who object to the new standards are upset because they now have to operate outside their comfort zone or conform to acceptable historical standards.

In short, it comes down to a simple standard recently highlighted by a progressive American Civil War chat board - What should your goals be when you attend a quality living history event at a reputable site? In short, the event is not about YOU…it’s about the objectives and goals of the site.

As a reenactor, you should adhere to two common standards… your personal expectations and the site's expectations.
 

Regarding personal expectations, you must be physically ready for the effort required Your kit must meet site standards, and you be mentally ready to do what is required. This includes knowing the drill, understanding the history behind the event, and being prepared to educate the public on the event's purpose. 
 
If your position is “the public doesn’t know any better,” and you intend to mislead guests, you must step aside and find a new hobby.
 

Regarding the site expectations, please remember their goals and objectives supersede ours. We must, without question, hold our wants, desires, and comforts as subservient to the event organizers' goals and objectives. If the event organizers wish to set high standards, we must strive to support them. A site does not exist to serve us…we support the site.

So in summary…naysayers of Battle Road remember three things: objections, grumblings, and complaining will get you nowhere. Either support progress and evolving standards or step aside. Second, if you object…and we encourage you to do so …be prepared to support your claim with documentation. Finally, our personal needs are subservient to those of the site.

And with that, we hope this will be the last editorial from the Nerds in a long, long time.
 
The views of this editorial reflect those of Historical Nerdery only and do not incorporate or reflect any official position of Minute Man National Historical Park or it's employees.

Friday, March 31, 2023

"I Was Horror-Struck" - Lexington's Rebekah Fiske's Eye Witness Account of April 19, 1775

A couple of months ago, we discussed four known accounts of women who came in direct contact with His Majesty’s forces on April 19, 1775.

Thanks to the research efforts of Minute Man National Historical Park, we now know of a 5th account from a civilian trapped between hostile forces during the Battles of Lexington and Concord.

Before we discuss Ms. Rebekah Fiske of Lexington, let’s quickly review the other four accounts.

First up is Lincoln’s Mary Hartwell, who remembered coming in close contact with retreating British forces just as they were about to enter the Bloody Curve. “I saw an occasional horseman dashing by, going up and down, but heard nothing more until I saw them coming back in the afternoon all in confusion, wild with rage and loud with threats. I knew there had been trouble and that it had not resulted favorably for their retreating army. I heard musket shots just below by the old Brooks Tavern and trembled, believing that our folks were killed.”


As they fled the family tavern, Anna Munroe's wife of Lexington’s Sergeant William Munroe and her 5-year-old daughter Anna nearly collided with the Royal Artillery and Percy's Relief Column. According to her 19th Century account, the child witness recalled she “could remember seeing the men in redcoats coming toward the house and how frightened her mother was when they ran from the house. That was all she could remember, but her mother told her of her very unhappy afternoon. She held Anna by the hand, brother William by her side and baby Sally in her arms . . . She could hear the cannon firing over her head on the hill. She could smell the smoke of the three buildings which the British burned between here and the center of Lexington. And she did not know what was happening to her husband, who was fighting, or what was happening within her house.”

Perhaps the most notable female non-combatant who came into direct contact with the retreating British column was Hannah Adams of Menotomy. As previously discussed, the Menotomy Fight of April 19, 1775 was a vicious engagement that devolved into a bloody house-to-house and room-to-room fight for survival. Unfortunately, as this fight raged on, Hannah Adams was trapped between Massachusetts militiamen and British regulars.

Like Hannah Adams, Hannah Bradish of Menotomy was also bedridden on April 19, 1775, having given birth to a child eight days earlier. As the regulars entered Menotomy, Hannah slept in bed with her infant. The fighting noise woke her up, and she quickly gathered her children and fled to the family kitchen at the back of the house.

According to her statement submitted to the Massachusetts Provincial Congress on May 11, 1775, “Hannah Bradish, of that part of Cambridge, called Menotomy, and daughter of timothy Paine, of Worcester, in the county of Worcester, esq. of lawful age, testifies and says, that about five o'clock on Wednesday last, afternoon, being in her bed-chamber, with her infant child, about eight days old, she was surprised by the firing of the king's troops and our people, on their return from Concord. She being weak and unable to go out of her house, in order to secure herself and family, they all retired into the kitchen, in the back part of the house. She soon found the house surrounded with the king's troops; that upon observation made, at least seventy bullets were shot into the front part of the house; several bullets lodged in the kitchen where she was, and one passed through an easy chair she had just gone from. The door of the front part of the house was broken open; she did not see any soldiers in the house, but supposed, by the noise, they were in the front. 

Artwork by Don Troiani

Recently Minute Man National Historical Park published an article on Lexington’s Rebekah Fiske. Admittedly, like Hannah Bradish, the Nerds were unaware of this account as well. We apologize, and moving forward, we promise we won’t be distracted by jars of frosting while researching the civilian experience of April 19th.

Rebekah Howe was born in Concord, Massachusetts. On May 14, 1767, she married Benjamin Fiske and moved to his family’s homestead in Lexington, near the Lincoln line. She was twenty-six years old in 1775.

In the early morning of April 19th, word reached the Fiske family that His Majesty’s forces were advancing on Concord. As many of her neighbors fled for safety, Rebekah was in a difficult situation. Her 83-year-old father-in-law, Lieutenant Ebenezer Fiske, was seriously ill and bedridden. At the same time, her husband was also suffering from some unknown impairment and was excused from militia service. As a result, she made the difficult choice of staying in her home.

While there, she heard the echo of gunshots from the Battle of Lexington and, soon thereafter, observed British troops pass her home. According to a 19th century narrative she shared with the Harvard Register, Fiske recalled, “I heard the guns … at about day-break, but being unapprehensive of danger, did not, like most of our neighbors move off for fear of the enemy; especially as my father was confined to his bed of a severe sickness so that in fleeing from the house we must leave him behind, which I could not consent to. Our domestics had already absconded, we knew not whither. I, therefore, and my husband, who on account of a certain indisposition, was incapacitated for military service, remained in the house with our father, while the enemy passed; which they did without offering us any injury. I remember well, their exact order, red coats, glittering arms, and appalling numbers.”

As previous research has suggested, many women and children who fled their homes earlier in the day returned mid-morning. According to Fiske, once word reached their location that the British were marching from Concord back to their location, a panic set in, and many civilians started to flee again.

 
Photo Credit John Collins
 
As the regulars approached, Fiske describes how she, her family, enslaved persons and many of her neighbors made a mad dash across fields to escape the coming firefight. 
 
"Sometime after, on their arrival at Concord, a report of musketry was once more heard, and in broken and incessant volleys. It was a sound of death to us. All now was trepidation, fever, and rushing to arms; women and children bewildered and scouring across the fields. With much ado we succeeded in yoking our oxen and getting father on his bed into an ox-cart, and thus moving him off as carefully as we could to a neighbor’s house, at some distance from the highway, on which we expected the enemy to return. Before leaving our house, I secured some of the most valuable of my effects, putting my large looking glass between two featherbeds, and fastening all the windows and doors. The house we carried farther to, had been already vacated, and here I was left alone with him. The dreadful sound of approaching guns was still ringing min my ears. Bewildered and affrighted, I betook myself into the house-cellar there to await my fate. Occasionally, I ventured to peep out to discover the approach of the enemy. After remaining some time in this dreadful state of fear and suspense, I at last discovered the enemy coming down a long hill on the highway partly upon a run and in some confusion, being closely beset by ‘our men’ in flank and rear. The terrific array of war soon came fully into view, and as soon passed off again from before my eyes, like a horrid vision, leaving only a cloud of smoke behind and the groans of the dying, who were strewed in its wake.”

Once the retreating army had passed her homestead, Rebekah returned to survey the damage. Upon arrival, she discovered a horrific scene. Not only had her home and surrounding property been vandalized and pillaged (both capital crimes in 18th Century Massachusetts), but she also discovered multiple casualties on the doorstep and inside her home. One of the dying was Acton minute man and school teacher James Haywood, mortally wounded earlier while exchanging musket fire with a British soldier at the Fiske’s water well.

As Rebekah graphically recalled in her 1827 statement “After the rattle of musketry had grown somewhat weaker from distance, and my heart became more relieved of its apprehensions, I resolved to return home. But what an altered scene began to present itself, as I approached the house—garden walls thrown down—my flowers trampled upon—earth and herbage covered with the marks of hurried footsteps. The house had been broken open, and on the door-step—awful spectacle—there lay a British soldier dead, on his face, though yet warm, in his blood, which was still trickling from a bullet-hole through his vitals. His bosom and his pockets were stuffed with my effects, which he had been pillaging, having broken into the house through a window. On entering my front room, I was horror-struck. Three mangled soldiers lay groaning on the floor and weltering in their blood which had gathered in large puddles about them. “Beat out my brains, I beg of you,” cried one of them, a young Briton, who was dreadfully pierced with bullets, through almost every part of his body, “and relieve me from this agony.” You will die soon enough, said I, with a revengeful pique. A grim Irishman, shot through the jaws, lay beside him, who mingled his groans of desperation with curses on the villain who had so horridly wounded him. The third was a young American employing his dying breath in prayer. A bullet had passed through his body, taking off in its course the lower part of his powder-horn. The name of this youthful patriot was J. Haywood of Acton. His father came and carried his body home; it no lies in Acton graveyard. These were the circumstances of his death: being ardent and close in the pursuit, he stopped a moment at our well to slake his thirst. Turning from the well, his eye unexpectedly caught that of the Briton, whom I saw lying dead on the door-step, just coming from the house with his plunder. They were about a rod from each other. The Briton know it was death for him to turn, and the American scorned to shrink. A moment of awful suspense ensued—when both simultaneously levelled their muskets at each other’s heart, fired, and fell on their faces together. My husband drew the two Britons off on a sled, and buried them in one of our pastures, where they now lie, beneath a pine tree which has grown up out of their grave. The Irishman was the only one of the three that survived.”
 
Photo Credit Asher Lurie

Rebekah's father-in-law died December 1775. She remained in Lexington until her husband died in 1785. The next year, she married again and moved to Bedford with her husband, William Merriam.

The Nerds will continue to collect period civilian accounts of April 19th. If you are aware of any depositions, claims or interviews that we overlooked, please do not hesitate to let us know!

Sunday, March 12, 2023

"At the Request of the Officers ... I Prayed With Them" - The Role of Ministers on April 19, 1775

Recently, the Nerds received an inquiry from a Ladies Association of Revolutionary America (LARA) member asking about ministers' roles during the Battles of Lexington and Concord.

We did some digging and found several accounts describing various roles that ministers undertook on April 19, 1775 and the days afterward. Please keep in mind this is merely an overview and a deeper dive is certainly needed.

As a preliminary matter, let’s quickly review the role of ministers in 18th Century New England society. The clergy stood at the pinnacle of 18th-century society. Due to their considerable talents and bolstered by the religious doctrines of the 17th and 18th centuries, ministers were considered the essential individual in a community’s social hierarchy. They were viewed as the community’s spiritual and moral leaders, the political commentators, the arbitrators of disputes and, when the town was without a schoolteacher, the educators as well. In short, they played a critical role in 18th Century New England society.

When His Majesty’s troops left Boston and marched towards Concord, a panic spread throughout Middlesex County. How did the spiritual leaders of Massachusetts respond?

In Lexington, the Reverend Jonas Clarke assumed an advisory and leadership role. Throughout the evening of April 18, 1775, he hosted John Hancock and Samuel Adams at his parsonage. When alarm riders Paul Revere and William Dawes arrived to alert the pair that a military expedition was advancing towards Lexington, Clarke immediately assumed a leadership role. According to the minister, he met with the town’s militia officers and men to “consult what might be done for our own and the people's safety; and also, to be ready for whatever service Providence might call us out to upon this alarming occasion, in case--just in case--overt acts of violence or open hostilities should be committed by this mercenary band of armed and blood-thirsty oppressors.”

Once it was determined that Captain John Parker’s company would remain in the vicinity to protect the town, the Reverend Clarke returned home to help his wife and children hide valuables. Afterward, he likely led several Lexington families to an area of safety away from the British line of march.

Photo Credit: John Collins

In the aftermath of the Battle of Lexington, Clarke assumed the role of a spiritual leader. According to a 19th-century account from his daughter, the Reverend Clarke“sent Jonas down to Grandfather Cook's to see who was killed and what their condition was and, in the afternoon, Father, Mother with me and the baby went to the Meeting House. There was the eight men that was killed, seven of them my Father's parishioners, one from Woburn, all in Boxes made of four large boards nailed up and, after Pa had prayed, they were put into two horse carts and took into the graveyard where some of the neighbors had made a large trench, as near the woods as possible and there we followed the bodies of those first slain, Father, Mother, I and the baby, there I stood and there I saw them let down into the ground, it was a little rainy but we waited to see them covered up with clods and then for fear the British should find them, my Father thought some of the men had best cut some pine or oak bows and spread them on their place of burial so that it looked like a heap of brush.”

According to local tradition, Clarke and John Parker then rallied the Lexington men and convinced them to re-enter the fight against His Majesty’s forces.

According to Minute Man National Historical Park, the Reverend William Emerson played an active role in the formation and spiritual guidance of the Concord minute companies. In March, 1775, the minister gave a sermon to the town’s minute companies proclaiming "Arise! my injured countrymen! and plead even with the sword, the firelock and the bayonet, plead with your arms the birthright of Englishmen, the dearly-purchased legacy left you by your never-to-be-forgotten Ancestors..."

On April 19th, Emerson joined the town’s minute companies when they first mustered at approximately one or two in the morning and was with them later that morning as they climbed the "eminence" north of town to watch the British troops approaching. According to family tradition, Emerson then retired to his home to watch over his family. According to other local historians, the minister rejoined the Concord minute companies and fought side by side with them.

When word of the Battle of Lexington reached Needham, Massachusetts, the Reverend Samuel West elected to follow the town’s militia company into battle as its spiritual leader. According to West, ““The news reached us about nine o’clock A.M. The east company in Needham met at my house as part of the Military stores were deposited with me, they there supplied themselves, and by ten o’clock all marched for the place of action with as much spirit and resolution as the most zealous friends of the cause could have wished for. We could easily trace the march of troops from the smoke which arose over them, and could hear from my house the report of the cannon and the Platoons fired by the British. The Needham company was soon on the ground, but unhappily being ignorant of what are called flank-guards they inserted themselves between them and the main body of the British troops. In consequence of which they suffered more severely than their Neighbors who kept to a greater distance.”

Later that evening, the Reverend West received word that several of the men from his community were among the day’s casualties. As a result, he immediately assumed the role of grief counselor and spiritual advisor. “In the evening we had intelligence that several of the Needham inhabitants were among the slain, and the next morning it was confirmed that five had fallen in the action and several others had been wounded. It is remarkable that the five who fell all of them had families, and several of them very numerous families so that there were about forty widows and fatherless children made in consequence of their death … I visited these families immediately, and with a sympathetic sense of their affliction I gave to some the first intelligence they had of the dreadful event, the death of a Husband and a Parent. The very different manner in which the tidings were received, discovered the very different disposition of the suffers. While some were almost frantic in their grief others received the news with profound silence as if in a consternation of grief they were incapable of shedding tears or uttering sighs or groans.”

The Reverend Andrew Elliott remained in Boston on the eve of the Revolution to watch over his remaining congregation. As news trickled about the engagement in Lexington, the minister noted many Bostonians were in an utter state of panic. “Such a Sabbath of melancholy and darkness I never knew … every face gathering paleness – all hurry & confusion – one going this way & another that – others not knowing where to go.” Elliott would be called upon to offer emotional and spiritual support to those who were now trapped behind enemy lines.

Photo Credit: John Collins 

In some communities, especially those outside the path of the fight, ministers often remained behind to tend to the flock and provide spiritual encouragement to those provincial units passing through the town en route to Boston.

In the days after Lexington and Concord, Newburyport ministers offered religious guidance to New Hampshire and Maine troops who passed through their community.

In Westborough, the Reverend Ebenezer Parkman offered sermons to those militia and minute companies that passed through his town. According to one passage, Parkman noted “The said Soldiers, having eat Breakfast here, left us; and two more came, viz. Appleton Osgood and Joseph Bowman from the Same Town, and had Breakfast among us. I rode to Northborough. At the Widow Martyns a multitude from South Hadley marching to Cambridge. I gave them (the soldiers) a Serious Exhortation and Caution.”

A few days later, Parkman noted “At the Request of the Officers of the Mansfield and Coventry Companys I prayed with them.”

Several ministers served either as eyewitnesses to the horrors of war and recorded the observations of others. According to the Reverend Parkman, he interviewed a Mr. Thomas Whitney, who had rid down as far as Charleston. He has Seen the Sad Effects of hot Assaults and Skirmishes. The Account that the Roads for a great way were strowed with dead Men, is confirmed.”

The Reverend David McCulure noted as he toured the aftermath of the Menotomy fight ““Dreadful were the vestiges of war on the road. I saw several dead bodies, principally British, on & near the road. They were all naked, having been stripped, principally, by their own soldiers. They lay on their faces. Several were killed who stopped to plunder & were suddenly surprised by our people pressing upon their rear.... The houses on the road of the march of the British, were all perforated with balls, & the windows broken. Horses, cattle & swine lay dead around. Such were the dreadful trophies of war, for about 20 Miles!”

Finally, the Reverend William Gordon, “you would have been shocked at the destruction which has been made by the Regulars, as they are miscalled, had you been present with me to have beheld it. Many houses were plundered of everything valuable that could be taken away, and what could not be carried off was destroyed.”

Obviously the Nerds need to take a closer look at this topic. So, if you have any leads or suggestions we should review, let us know!